Public Beta · Not legal advice
← Interactive map

United States · US-004

Doe v GitHub

PLEADING SURVIVEDU.S. District Court for the Northern District of California; U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit4:22-cv-06823; 9th Cir. 24-7700Interlocutory appeal pending
Copyright Management Information / DMCA §1202OutputsTrainingLicensing

Key holding or allegation

The matter produced substantive CMI rulings and an interlocutory Ninth Circuit appeal; final appellate resolution had not been identified by the cutoff.

Why it matters

Leading U.S. generative-code copyright/CMI matter.

Facts

Open-source developers challenged Copilot's use and output of code, including alleged removal or alteration of copyright-management information.

Issues before the court

Among other questions, whether DMCA section 1202 requires generated output to be identical to the work from which CMI was allegedly removed.

What the court did not decide

No final appellate holding yet and no categorical determination of Copilot training legality.

Procedural timeline

2024

U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
Interlocutory appeal opened: Interlocutory appeal concerns GitHub Copilot copyright-management-information issues, including the relationship between generated output and source work.

PLEADING SURVIVED